258 Bay Street, Orillia

258 Bay Street
258 Bay Street
258 Bay Street
+45
4
 bed
3
 bath
6
 parking
3000 - 3500
 sqft
Detached
Sold conditional
Listed for 
$1,499,900
Sold conditional
90 days
 on site
Sold conditional
Listed for 
$1,499,900
Click to open the pre-gallery to get the direction
Size
-
Lot size
-
Street frontage
-
Possession
90+ days
Price per sqft
$429 - $500
Taxes
$8,991.03 (2026)
Parking Type
-
Style
2 1/2 Storey
See what's nearby
Description
This premium waterfront property offers an exceptional location just minutes from Orillia's downtown core and Couchiching Beach Park. Situated on a deep, mature lot with expansive, unobstructed views of the water, the main residence spans approximately 3,200 square feet, featuring four bedrooms, three bathrooms and is highlighted by unique architectural details such as a striking curved dining room with floor-to-ceiling windows, a grand spiral staircase and a spacious living area. Adding significant versatility to the property is a fully finished caretakers premises on the lower level with waterfront views. Combining substantial square footage, unmistakable character and rare waterfront proximity to Orillia's amenities, this property presents a remarkable opportunity in a highly sought-after neighbourhood.
Broker: Royal LePage Quest
MLS®#: S13511876
Property details
Parking:
6
Parking type:
-
Property type:
Detached
Heating type:
Water
Style:
2 1/2 Storey
MLS Size:
3000-3500 sqft
Lot front:
55 Ft
Lot depth:
276 Ft
Listed on:
Jul 2, 2026
Show all details
Rooms
LevelNameSizeFeatures
Main
Bathroom
6.8 x 6.0 ft
Second
Bedroom 3
8.9 x 13.1 ft
Second
Bathroom
9.7 x 6.8 ft
Show all
Instant estimate:
orto view instant estimate
$67,025
lower than listed price
i
High
$1,506,912
Mid
$1,432,875
Low
$1,375,659
Have a home? See what it's worth with an instant estimate

Use our AI-assisted tool to get an instant estimate of your home's value, up-to-date neighbourhood sales data, and tips on how to sell for more.

1273 HAWK RIDGE Crescent
1/48
$1,499,000
16 days
1273 HAWK RIDGE Crescent
3+3BD
4BA
10 Parking
3,000-3,500 sqft
MLS#: S13778840
Century 21 B.J. Roth Realty Ltd.
16 days

About 258 Bay Street

258 Bay Street is an Orillia detached house for sale. It has been listed at $1499900 since July 2026. This 3000-3500 sqft detached house has 4 beds and 3 bathrooms.

Groceries can be found at Foodland which is only an 8 minute walk and you'll find Maximum Mobility & Access Centre an 8-minute walk as well. 258 Bay St, Orillia is a 4-minute walk from great parks like Couchiching Beach Park and Hillcrest Park.

Living in this detached house is easy. There is also The Birchmere Bus Stop, a short distance away, with route Laclie nearby.