Search for  real estate by price, bedroom, or property type. View all the latest MLS® listings.
Market Overview
The East Bayfield rental market for houses for rent offers a strong mix of choice and competition, making it a destination worth watching for anyone comparing options across the region. Right now, there are 10 active listings, giving prospective tenants a helpful snapshot of what’s available at any given moment. Current listings average around $2,322, providing a practical benchmark for budgeting, while the typical home spends about 52 days on the market—an indicator of how quickly rentals are being leased.
Recent movement, reflected in -15.2%, suggests the market may be trending upward or downward depending on current conditions. For renters, this can influence negotiation leverage, timing, and how quickly to act when the right home appears. For property owners and investors, the same figures can help frame pricing strategy and expectations. Overall, East Bayfield continues to attract attention because it balances everyday liveability with a range of rental housing styles and layouts.
Browse Listings
Exploring the 10 available houses for rent in East Bayfield is one of the best ways to understand what the local rental landscape looks like today. Inventory can shift quickly, so browsing active listings helps renters compare layouts, features, and neighbourhood pockets in real time.
Options often range from cozy starter homes to larger properties designed for growing households, offering flexibility for different lifestyles and budgets. Since this page focuses on homes for rent, it’s designed to make the search process easier—whether someone is relocating, upgrading space, or simply looking for a better fit. With a clear view of current availability, it becomes simpler to shortlist properties, track pricing, and decide when to book showings.
Pricing Insights
Pricing for houses for rent in East Bayfield is best understood by looking at both the overall average and the range of what’s currently available. The average listing price sits at $2,322, offering a useful reference point when comparing homes by size, condition, and location. For a deeper value comparison across different property styles, the average price per square foot is $0, which helps renters evaluate whether a home’s monthly rent aligns with its space and perceived quality.
It’s also important to consider the broader spread: current listings fall within $1,550 - $3,995. A wider range can reflect a market with everything from more budget-friendly options to premium rentals with larger footprints, additional bedrooms, or upgraded finishes. Since availability and demand can change quickly, watching how long listings remain active—around 52 days—can help renters gauge how competitive certain price points may be and whether acting sooner could improve the chances of securing a preferred home.
Average Prices by Bedroom
Bedrooms Avg. Price Listings 1 Bed $1,550 1 2 Beds $1,846 6 3 Beds $3,532 3 Living in the Area
Life in East Bayfield tends to appeal to renters who want a comfortable day-to-day rhythm with a sense of neighbourhood identity. The area’s overall character can feel established and community-oriented, with many streets offering a mix of housing types that suit different stages of life. Some residents prioritize having more interior space for work-from-home setups or shared living arrangements, while others focus on finding a home that supports a quieter routine or a more active schedule.
Walkability and getting around are often key considerations for renters, and the feel of the streetscape can influence which pockets people prefer—whether they want to be closer to everyday errands or tucked a bit farther into residential sections. A strong community feel can also come from the way the area is used: local streets that encourage casual walks, neighbours who settle in for longer tenancies, and a general sense that the area supports both convenience and comfort.
For households comparing layouts, homes in this area can be attractive because they often provide room to grow—think extra bedrooms, storage, or flexible spaces that can be used for hobbies, guests, or home offices. Ultimately, choosing houses for rent in East Bayfield is as much about lifestyle fit as it is about price: the best match is usually the one that aligns with commuting needs, preferred pace of life, and the kind of space that makes daily routines easier.
Market Trends
The table below highlights how current conditions compare across key indicators, helping renters and landlords understand where the market is heading and how today’s listings fit into broader patterns.
Market Trends
Period Avg. Price Listings Avg. DOM Current $2,322 10 52 days Last 12 Months $2,496 33 21 days Last 90 Days $2,308 13 46 days What's Nearby
For transit access, Michael Crescent is approximately 242.28650630101, offering a convenient option for commuters and anyone who prefers to get around without relying solely on a car. Everyday shopping is supported by nearby options such as BulkBarn, making it easier to manage errands and weekly routines.
When it’s time to unwind outdoors, residents can take advantage of green space around East Bayfield Park and Cartwright Park, which can be ideal for walks, casual recreation, or simply getting fresh air close to home. Those who enjoy a quick stop for coffee can find one at Tim Hortons.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the average price of houses for rent in East Bayfield?
The average listing price for houses for rent in East Bayfield is currently $2,322. This figure is a helpful starting point for budgeting, but actual pricing can vary based on factors like size, condition, and where the home is located within the area.
How many houses are available for rent in East Bayfield right now?
There are 10 active listings for houses for rent in East Bayfield. Because rental inventory can change frequently, checking back often can help renters spot new opportunities quickly.
How long do rentals typically stay on the market in East Bayfield?
On average, listings spend about 52 days on the market. A shorter timeframe can signal strong demand, while a longer timeframe may create more room for comparison shopping and scheduling viewings.
Is the East Bayfield market trending up or down for houses for rent?
Market direction is reflected in -15.2%. When prices trend upward, renters may need to act faster or broaden criteria; when prices trend downward, there may be more flexibility in finding value while still focusing on preferred features and location.
Looking for your next favourite place to eat? There is a lot close by .Grab your morning coffee at Tim Hortons located at 181 Livingstone St E. Groceries can be found at BulkBarn which is a 9-minute walk and you'll find Bob Griffith RMT not far as well. If you're an outdoor lover, you are a short distance away from East Bayfield Park and Cartwright Park.
Getting around the area will require a vehicle, as the nearest transit stop is a York Region Transit BusStop (METRO RD / SHEPPARD AV) and is a 28-minute drive