Search for  real estate by price, bedroom, or property type. View all the latest MLS® listings.
Market Overview
The rental market for properties for rent in Innisfil offers a snapshot of current availability, pricing, and pace—useful for anyone comparing options before booking showings. Right now, there are 154 active listings, providing a meaningful selection across different layouts and building styles. The average listing price is $2,701, with homes typically spending about 53 days on the market. This combination of supply and timing can help renters understand how quickly they may need to act when a good match appears.
Recent movement in pricing is reflected in -4.8%, offering a quick read on whether rents are trending upward or easing. When prices shift, the best approach is to focus on value: condition, space, and location within the community. With a range of property types and features, Innisfil continues to attract interest from renters looking for a balance of comfort, commute-friendly living, and everyday convenience—especially when comparing similar options across nearby neighbourhoods.
Browse Listings
Explore 154 available properties for rent in Innisfil to get a feel for what’s currently on the market. Listings often vary widely in layout, natural light, storage, parking arrangements, and building amenities, making it worthwhile to review multiple options before narrowing down a shortlist. Depending on what’s available, renters may find everything from efficient, low-maintenance spaces to larger homes designed for more flexibility.
Because this page focuses on properties for rent, it’s a helpful starting point for comparing locations, features, and budget. As inventory changes, revisiting the listings regularly can uncover new opportunities—especially for those seeking a specific 4+-bedroom setup or a particular style within properties.
Pricing Insights
Pricing for properties for rent in Innisfil is shaped by a mix of factors, including overall supply, property condition, size, and how each home is positioned within the local area. The current average listing price is $2,701, giving renters a useful benchmark when comparing different buildings and streets. For a more apples-to-apples comparison across properties of different sizes, the average price per square foot sits at $3, while average square footage is 880 sqft. Together, these metrics can help clarify whether a higher monthly price is primarily driven by added space, upgraded finishes, or other features.
At the broader level, the $620 - $10,000 range highlights the spread between entry-level options and higher-end rentals. Renters can use the range to set expectations early, then focus on the listings that best match their priorities—such as a preferred floor plan, outdoor space, included utilities, or proximity to everyday needs. For those comparing layouts, the breakdown below offers a helpful look at how pricing can vary by bedroom count.
Average Prices by Bedroom
Bedrooms Avg. Price Listings 1 Bed $1,850 35 2 Beds $2,478 63 3 Beds $3,365 28 4 Beds $3,612 26 5+ Beds $3,500 2 Living in the Area
Living in Innisfil appeals to renters who want a community feel paired with practical day-to-day convenience. The area’s character typically reflects a blend of established residential streets and pockets of newer development, creating a variety of housing options and streetscapes. Some parts may feel quieter and more residential, while others can be more active—closer to shopping, services, and transit connections. This mix can be especially attractive for renters who prefer to choose between a calmer setting and a more connected, on-the-go lifestyle.
Walkability and ease of getting around are often key considerations for tenants. Depending on where a property sits, errands and daily routines may be handled largely on foot, by bike, or via public transit, while drivers may prioritize access to main routes for commuting. Many renters also look for a sense of community—places that feel welcoming, offer a comfortable rhythm during the week, and provide opportunities to spend time outdoors when the weather is good.
Housing preferences in Innisfil can vary widely, which is part of its draw. Some renters want low-maintenance living in professionally managed buildings, while others prioritize extra space, privacy, or room to work from home. Regardless of the property type, the best approach is to align the listing with lifestyle needs first—then evaluate value based on condition, layout efficiency, and what’s included in the rent. That way, a chosen home supports both budget and long-term comfort.
Market Trends
To understand how today’s listings compare with recent activity, review the market trends snapshot below, including changes in pricing and timing.
Market Trends
Period Avg. Price Listings Avg. DOM Current $2,701 154 53 days Last 12 Months $2,932 429 33 days Last 90 Days $2,562 134 33 days Top Areas
Innisfil can include multiple pockets with distinct vibes and housing styles. The table below highlights top sub-areas to help narrow a search by location and availability.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the average price of properties for rent in Innisfil?
The current average listing price for properties for rent in Innisfil is $2,701. This figure is a useful baseline for comparing listings, but the final monthly rent can vary based on size, condition, included utilities, and building features. Reviewing both the average and the $620 - $10,000 range can help renters decide what represents good value for their needs.
How many properties for rent are available in Innisfil right now?
There are 154 active listings currently available. Because rental inventory can change quickly, renters may want to check back often—especially if they’re targeting a specific 4+-bedroom configuration or have must-have requirements like parking, pet policies, or in-suite laundry.
How long do rentals typically stay on the market in Innisfil?
On average, listings spend about 53 days on the market. A shorter average can indicate faster-moving demand, while a longer timeframe may provide more room for comparison and scheduling. Regardless of timing, it helps to have documents and preferences ready so a strong option can be pursued quickly when it appears.
How can renters compare value between different properties in Innisfil?
Beyond monthly rent, comparing the average price per square foot ($3) and the typical size (880 sqft) can make it easier to evaluate value across different layouts and building types. Renters can also look at what’s included in rent, the efficiency of the floor plan, and how well the location fits their routine—then use the 154 available listings to benchmark similar options before deciding.
Nearby grocery options: 400 Market is a 5-minute drive.
Getting around the area will require a vehicle, as the nearest transit stop is a York Region Transit BusStop (METRO RD / RAINES ST) and is a 12-minute drive