4458 Plum Point Road

4458 Plum Point Road
4458 Plum Point Road
4458 Plum Point Road
+36
2+1
 bed
1
 bath
4
 parking
700 - 1100
 sqft
Detached
$850,000
For Sale
1 day
 on site
$850,000
Click to open the pre-gallery to get the direction
Size
-
Lot size
-
Street frontage
-
Possession
Flexible
Price per sqft
$773 - $1,214
Taxes
$2,736 (2025)
Parking Type
-
Style
Bungalow
See what's nearby
Description
This charming 3-season, fully renovated cottage on the shores of Lake Simcoe is tucked into a quiet bay at Mcdonald Beach, where the shallow, sandy bottom makes for ideal swimming for kids, paddle boarding, and fantastic fishing.Originally built as a cozy getaway, this property has been completely updated for modern comfort. The main cottage features 2 bedrooms and a 200 sq. ft loft area, an open concept kitchen/dining/living area, 3-piece bathroom, and a spacious living room with rustic wood beam ceilings. Wall-to-wall windows lets in an abundance of natural light and offers tranquil views of the lake. Extensive upgrades include: New roof (2021), Upgraded electrical panel, new, owned hot water tank, All walls spray foam insulated for energy efficiency and comfort and a new septic system (2019) pumped out 2024.A standout feature is the newly rebuilt bunkie (2021), measuring 8' x 24', perfect for extra guest space and storage. The property also includes a dock and water is drawn from the lake. This property is ready for your family to create years of unforgettable waterfront memories!
Broker: RE/MAX RIGHT MOVE
MLS®#: S12194259
Property details
Parking:
4
Parking type:
-
Property type:
Detached
Heating type:
Other
Style:
Bungalow
MLS Size:
700-1100 sqft
Lot front:
45 Ft
Lot depth:
180 Ft
Listed on:
Jun 4, 2025
Show all details
Instant estimate:
orto view instant estimate
$10,448
lower than listed price
i
High
$856,343
Mid
$839,552
Low
$751,177
Have a home? See what it's worth with an instant estimate

Use our AI-assisted tool to get an instant estimate of your home's value, up-to-date neighbourhood sales data, and tips on how to sell for more.

4304 Plum Point Road
1/28
$889,900
36 days
4304 Plum Point Road
3BD
1BA
2 Parking
700-1,100 sqft
MLS#: S12111898
Royal LePage Quest
36 days
4137 Bayview Avenue
1/19
$867,000
21 days
4137 Bayview Avenue
3BD
1BA
11 Parking
700-1,100 sqft
MLS#: S12149755
COLDWELL BANKER THE REAL ESTATE CENTRE
21 days
4027 Glen Cedar Drive
1/47
$749,000
119 days
4027 Glen Cedar Drive
3BD
2BA
8 Parking
700-1,100 sqft
MLS#: S11959558
Keller Williams Experience Realty
119 days
4705 ANDERSON Avenue
1/14
$750,000
17 days
4705 ANDERSON Avenue
2BD
1BA
4 Parking
700-1,100 sqft
MLS#: S12157686
RE/MAX CROSSTOWN REALTY INC.
17 days

About 4458 Plum Point Road

4458 Plum Point Road is an Orillia detached house for sale. It was listed at $850000 in June 2025 and has 2+1 beds and 1 bathroom.

For groceries there is McComishs Wee British Shoppe which is a 9-minute drive.

Getting around the area will require a vehicle, as the nearest transit stop is a Bus Stop (Atherley Road / Invermara Court) and is a 6-minute drive