2460 Effingham Street

2460 Effingham Street
2460 Effingham Street
2460 Effingham Street
+47
5
 bed
2
 bath
40
 parking
2000 - 2500
 sqft
Rural Resid
Sold for
$1,400,000
Listed for
$1,499,800
Sold on 
Oct 27, 2025
129 days
 on site
Sold for
$1,400,000
Listed for
$1,499,800
Click to open the pre-gallery to get the direction
Size
-
Lot size
16 sqft
Street frontage
-
Possession
30-59 days
Price per sqft
$560 - $700
Taxes
$2,941.37 (2025)
Parking Type
-
Style
1 1/2 Storey
See what's nearby
Description
Unbelievable 16.68-acre property featuring a fully renovated 5-bedroom century farmhouse on prestigious Effingham St with 2 road frontages. Numerous well-kept outbuildings include the original 3-storey dairy barn with concrete silo. The lower level houses chickens and geese with a walk-in cooler; the 2nd and 3rd levels showcase exposed hand-hewn beams, planks, a stage area, and 4-piece bathroom. A loft/bar area makes it perfect for parties and events. The original milk house has been converted into a heated, insulated workspace with tile floors, currently used as a wellness/therapy office. A transfer box for a generator hookup has been put in which can run the whole property, natural gas line to this majestic barn. A detached 23 x 35 brick/block shop/garage has 220V power and overhead doors, one 9' high. Also included are a 50 x 50 implement shed, 50 x 100 coverall, pond, bunkie, and lean-to picnic area. 12 Mile Creek runs through the bush and meadow, home to wildlife like deer and turkeys. Conservation & Ducks Unlimited planted 4000 trees in recent years. Apple, cherry, plum trees, and raspberries grow in the backyard. There's a good-sized horse paddock with a walk-in shed and frost-free water system. Approx. 5 acres are in cash crop, plus an additional 10 acres rented by the owner, reducing property taxes significantly. A covered side porch leads into a tiled mudroom. A second front entrance opens to a hardwood foyer, original parlor (office), and living room with wide plank floors and French doors. Main floor includes a 3-piece bath, spacious kitchen with granite countertops, laundry room with separate shower and pantry. Step out to a wood deck with a hot tub and gazebo. Upstairs: 5 bedrooms (4 w/wide plank floors) and a 3-piece bath with skylight and glass shower. Full basement with 200 amp service, 1yr new gas on-demand water system, sump pump, central vac, filtration system, and 2yr new central air. Don't miss this rare opportunity!
Broker: RE/MAX GARDEN CITY REALTY INC, BROKERAGE
MLS®#: X12235325
Property details
Parking:
40
Parking type:
-
Property type:
Rural Resid
Heating type:
Water
Style:
1 1/2 Storey
MLS Size:
2000-2500 sqft
Lot front:
445 Ft
Lot depth:
1059 Ft
Listed on:
Jun 20, 2025
Show all details

About 2460 Effingham Street

2460 Effingham Street is a Pelham rural resid which was for sale. It was listed at $1499800 in June 2025 but is no longer available and has been taken off the market (Sold) on 27th of October 2025.. This rural resid has 5 beds, 2 bathrooms and is 2000-2500 sqft.

For groceries or a pharmacy you'll likely need to hop into your car as there is not much near this rural resid.

Getting around the area will require a vehicle, as the nearest transit stop is a Bus Stop (Macturnbull Dr / Vansickle Rd) and is a 7-minute drive